Pete and Repete were sitting in a boat.

Pete fell out. Who was left?

{ Tiffany & Co. }

Last October, we thought we had picked out our wedding bands. Fast forward a few months, and I started having major doubts. It is important to us that our rings not be apart of the overall wedding budget– i.e. we each personally pay for the other’s ring. My art-hippie-student-self can’t afford to drop $2,000 on a band, and I wasn’t keen on the idea of begging him to spend that much on a band if I were only able to afford a quarter of that price. So, back to the drawing board.

Because Tiffany & Co. has little-to-no white gold wedding bands, I knew we would need to meander away from our jewelry mecca. Having our bands in platinum, especially his, jacked the price up astronomically, so white gold it is. After countless frustrating Saturdays filled with rings that we were “meh” over, we decided on two bands from Mayors & Birks.

{ Birks }

They were white gold, half the price of the Tiffany rings, and very pretty. My band was a little “squared” in comparison to my engagement ring, but it still looked very nice next to it. “Very nice” and “pretty” and other things I told myself about the ring started to wear off– I realized that I was ambivalent about a ring that JP would be spending a whole heckuvalotta dough on. Make no mistake, the ring is wonderful, but it just didn’t feel 100% right. Insert some bridal “you know when it’s the one” cliche phrases, and you’ll know where I stand reasoning-wise. It just wasn’t… there.

Enter serendipity, a random Google search, and a ring that I fell head-over-heels in love with– both in looks and price.

{ Whiteflash }

3mm width? Check. White gold? Check. Way under $1,000? Check. Sparklers? Check. More diamonds and higher weight than the previous choice? Double check. Comfort fit? Check. HELLO, WINNER!

Unfortunately for our heroes, both of the rings cannot be purchased at Whiteflash, because JP has giant hands. Whiteflash only makes their mens’ rings up to a size 10. (I should note that it is not unfortunate that JP has giant hands. I am quite a fan of his large-handedness. Sexy and whatnot…) I’ve gotten over my “OUR RINGS HAVE TO BE FROM THE SAME PLACE OMG!” weirdness, and so his ring will be coming from the lovely folks over at Blue Nile.

{ Blue Nile }

6mm, white gold, comfort fit, way under $1,000, and comes in JP’s ring size. We are big fans.

So there you have our probably-entirely-too-long-winded-nobody-really-cares “finding the bands” story. From start to finish it has taken eight months of looking, deciding, whining, and mind-changing, but we’re ending up with rings we both love and can afford. Moral of the story? If you’re having trouble finding something that fits your taste AND budget, keep on truckin’, and hopefully you’ll find something fabulous and affordable.

How did you approach ring shopping, and how did you decide on your bands? Was finding the perfect pair as easy as pie or a lot of lather-rinse-repeat-back-to-the-drawing-board?

show hide 6 comments

MarieMay 2, 2010 - 11:35 pm

I like! Of course, I may be biased because that is exactly the wedding band that I have. Good taste.

Chichi {From Now Till I do}May 3, 2010 - 6:03 am

Love your wedding band. FI and I were having the very same conversation this morning. We’ve gone for similar characteristics e.g. white gold (everything else, way too expensive), matching – maybe with diamonds.

Our wedding rings are a gift by a family member, so we have had to give our sizes and what we’re looking for and she will will purchase them overseas and bring to the wedding.

NetanyaMay 7, 2010 - 7:59 pm

I love the final rings you picked out! With so many options as what to get in a wedding ring, it can be completely overwhelming! But it looks like you were able to narrow it down. I absolutely love Blue Nile by the way. Good choice. Congratulations to you both!

Thanks for sharing this,

Netanya
netanya@engagementring.org

LanaMay 9, 2010 - 3:37 pm

FH is in the Canadian Forces- and thus cannot wear his wedding band to work. He’s also very particular about what constitutes a “manly” ring and what doesn’t. For his band price is important- since he has to take it off every day and thus will most likely loose it, we don’t want to spend a ton on his ring- since we’ll probably be buying another in the not to distant future. He’s also not allowed Titanium or Tungsten as per CF rules. While shopping at the mall yesterday we found the ticket- dark stainless steel, squared, 50$. He loves it. He’s not terrified that if he looses it it’ll be the end of the world (because I know if he IS terrified, it’s more likely to get lost) and it’s “manly” enough for him.

I’m still on the search for my ideal channel-set princess cut five or ten stone band. (Five because it’ll be five years to the day that I met him when we get married, or ten for the those five years plus the next ten decades!) I WILL find it. I’ve found some contenders on Overstock.com!

Hilary / Lovely and GraciousMay 11, 2010 - 12:57 pm

Way to be thrifty! This is a great post and makes me think twice about dropping big bucks on a tiffany band to match my engagement ring. A little research sometimes goes a long way. Love the blog, btw… I’ll add it to my reader.!

AshleyMay 11, 2010 - 3:58 pm

I love the Whiteflash Scattered Diamond Band. They actually do make this in a size larger than a 10 all you have to do is call! =) Good luck!

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *

*

*

There was an error submitting your comment. Please try again.